HD DVD: It's Not Just a Flesh Wound
I’ve been watching HD DVD’s plummeting popularity since Warner’s decision to jump on the Blu-ray bandwagon, especially evident following CES. But Toshiba’s apparently not going down without a fight. In Bryan Gardiner’s article for Wired, he explains what may be their “Hail Mary” effort to stem the tide.
You’ve got to hand to Toshiba. Even now, when faced with overwhelming evidence that Sony’s Blu-ray has won the high def format war, the mortally wounded HD DVD backer just keeps on prolonging the inevitable.First, Toshiba decides to dramatically cut prices on its HD DVD players in the U.S. following Warner Bros. Blu-ray defection earlier this month. Now, for reasons that also escape us, the company has decided to buy a 30-second Super Bowl spot for $2.7 million to advertise its
desperationthose marked down HD DVD players.Of course, none of this is really convincing consumers. As Ars Technica recently noted, in the week following the Warner Bros. defection, weekly HD DVD player sales tanked big time, falling from 14,558 the week previous to a measly 1,758.
Meanwhile, Blu-ray saw a reverse trend, climbing from 15,257 to 21,770. In fact, the format ended up capturing approximately 93 percent of the market that week, according to NDP. …
We’ve watched the format war rage for nearly two years. The world’s apparently made its choice. Maybe it’s time for Toshiba to throw in the towel on this one.
Reader Comments (8)
It is like the VHF-Betamax wars. In that one, the wrong team won.
Yeah, am me with a big collection of HDs. Always goes that way. Now I'll need two players! Damn!
Love Monty Python!
No worries, just have two players and look like a tech geek.
Who knows, maybe the Super Bowl ad will turn the tide?
Let's hope so. I have a big investment here in HD.
You just know someone will make a player that will play both.
Have to agree with Doug. Too little agressive marketing, too late. HD thought that capitlizing on it's name with the surge in HD programming would suffice. Nope. Bigger guns and guerilla marketing by Sony worked better.
Sony won this time. Despite there Beta experience years ago. Look for the price of Blu-Ray players to drop about 40% in the coming months.
And like last time, Sony has the better product. No way they were going to have a repeat of the Beta fiasco. But they did win on that in a way - News crews and other professionals still use the BetaCams.